Netflix's New #1 Murder Mystery Movie Is Getting Stabbed in the Back by Audiences on Rotten Tomatoes

Netflix's new mystery movie, 'The Thursday Murder Club', is evoking mixed feelings on Rotten Tomatoes, dividing audiences as they critique its quaint murder plotline.
The Thursday Murder Club

A Murder Mystery with a Twist

In a world where thrillers and crime dramas often dominate streaming platforms, 'The Thursday Murder Club' offers something a bit different with its quaint narrative approach to murder mysteries. Adapted from the first novel in the bestselling series by Richard Osman, the movie tells the story of four septuagenarians who come together to investigate unsolved murders in their retirement village.


Audience Reactions

The film's unconventional approach has left audiences polarized. Many applaud its humor and uniqueness, while others find it lacking in depth and suspense. On Rotten Tomatoes, viewer reviews are a mixed bag. As one user eloquently put it, "It's like 'Murder She Wrote' meets a cozy afternoon tea, but with fewer thrills."


"If you want to catch fish, you have to go where the fish are." - Richard Osman

Why the Divide?

The divide seems to stem from the audience's expectations of a traditional murder mystery. Here are the key points causing the split:

  • Expectations vs. Reality: Fans of the novel expected a direct adaptation, while the movie takes creative liberties.
  • Pacing: Some viewers find the pacing slow, impacting engagement.
  • Character Depth: The focus on character development over thrills isn't everyone’s cup of tea.

Engaging Elements

Despite the backlash, there’s no denying the appeal of the film's quaint charm. Here's why some viewers are hooked:

  1. Unique Setting: The retirement village adds a fresh angle to the genre.
  2. Warm Humor: The film’s gentle humor resonates well with certain audiences.
  3. Ensemble Cast: The movie features seasoned actors like Helen Mirren, who bring their charm to the screen.

Exploring Further

If 'The Thursday Murder Club' intrigues you, consider diving into Richard Osman's original novel available on Amazon. Healthcare, friendships, and laughter intermingle with mystery to add layers to the narrative. Also, you can check movie reviews on Metacritic to get a more diversified opinion.


For those who appreciate a slow-burn mystery and quirky characters, 'The Thursday Murder Club' provides a charming deviation from the norm. The film’s narrative strategy—with its humor, warmth, and setting—may evoke nostalgia for those with a penchant for more traditional, logic-driven tales.


Richard Osman

Author of 'The Thursday Murder Club', Richard Osman.


Continue Reading at Source : MovieWeb